I’ve noticed that many readers are leaving comments and asking questions about coins they own that are both interesting and affordable. In fact, some of these coins are still found in everyday pocket change!
While I’ve written a few articles about inexpensive coins, I want to take a moment to highlight the top 10 coins that are getting a lot of attention. These coins are definitely worth collecting. Most of them are easy to find and won’t break the bank!
#1 Indian Head Pennies
Indian Head pennies are incredibly popular and should not be overlooked.
Believe it or not, the famous Indian Head penny is now over 100 years old, yet they are still available in decent grades for under $2 to $5.
Minted from 1859 to 1909, these coins are great for any collection. Be on the lookout for uncleaned, non-corroded examples (but don’t clean them yourself!). These pennies are abundant and affordable additions to a U.S. coin collection.
#2 Lincoln Wheat Pennies
The most common question I get revolves around the value of wheat pennies.
In fact, most wheat pennies are worth well under a dollar in circulated grades. These coins, struck from 1909 to 1958, are becoming more scarce over time. Despite this, the wheat penny remains one of the most popular and least expensive classic American coins. Collectors and non-collectors alike love these coins.
#3 Buffalo Nickels
The iconic Buffalo nickel, sometimes called the Indian Head nickel, was minted from 1913 to 1938.
This coin honors two classic American symbols: the bison and the American Indian. Buffalo nickels are highly regarded and are often seen as “romantic” in their design. They are available for under $2 and are an important historical piece for any collector of U.S. coins.
#4 Mercury Dimes
Despite common misconception, the profile on the Mercury dime is actually Liberty wearing a winged cap, not the Roman god Mercury.
Minted from 1916 to 1945, the Mercury dime (also known as the Winged Liberty Head dime) is a favorite among collectors. Many older collectors remember finding these coins in their pocket change, alongside Buffalo nickels and Indian Head pennies. These coins represent an ideal of freedom and are available for around $3 to $5.
#5 Standing Liberty Quarters
First minted in 1916 and continuing until 1930, the Standing Liberty quarter went through several design changes during its short 14-year run.
The initial design in 1916 caused controversy because Miss Liberty’s chest was exposed, so the U.S. Mint covered her with mail in 1917. That year also saw modifications to the reverse, including the repositioning of stars beneath the flying eagle. In 1925, the date was changed to prevent it from wearing off easily.
Standing Liberty quarters minted from 1916 to 1924 tend to be more expensive than those from 1925 to 1930. You can find later versions for under $10, but earlier ones begin at about $20.
#6 Walking Liberty Half Dollars
Regarded as one of the most beautiful U.S. coins, the Walking Liberty half dollar was struck from 1916 to 1947. This coin features Liberty striding toward a rising sun, with a bald eagle on the reverse.
These coins are available for under $10 and are a must-have for collectors who appreciate the artistic quality of U.S. coins.
#7 Franklin Half Dollars
Benjamin Franklin was never a president, but his many contributions as a Founding Father and inventor earned him a place on the U.S. half dollar from 1948 to 1963. A complete set of Franklin half dollars can be assembled easily, with many coins costing less than $10 each.
#8 Kennedy Half Dollars
Kennedy half dollars, minted since 1964, are popular among collectors. You can often find worn examples at your local bank, but if you want uncirculated versions, you’ll need to purchase them from a dealer. Uncirculated Kennedy half dollars typically cost less than $2 each, while silver versions from the 1960s are available for $5 to $7.
#9 Eisenhower Dollars
The Eisenhower dollar was introduced in 1971, reintroducing the silver dollar to the public after more than 35 years. Featuring President Dwight Eisenhower, the coin was produced for only seven years, with 32 different versions created. Most Eisenhower dollars can be found for $3 to $7 in uncirculated or proof versions.
#10 Susan B. Anthony Dollars
After the Eisenhower dollar was discontinued in 1978, the Susan B. Anthony dollar was introduced in 1979. Smaller than previous dollar coins, this coin was often mistaken for a quarter and was phased out by 1981. However, it made a brief return in 1999.
Susan B. Anthony dollars are available for $2 to $3 in uncirculated grades and typically cost between $5 to $7 in proof versions.
FAQ
Are these coins easy to find?
Yes, most of these coins are still commonly found in pocket change or can be purchased for a low cost through various coin dealers.
How do I determine the value of my coins?
The value of a coin depends on its condition, rarity, and demand. You can check recent auction prices, consult a price guide, or ask a professional coin dealer to get an estimate.
Should I clean my coins to improve their appearance?
It’s best not to clean your coins, as cleaning can decrease their value. Let the natural patina of the coin remain intact.
Are these coins good investments?
While many of these coins are affordable, some can appreciate in value over time, especially rare or well-preserved examples. Collecting them for enjoyment is a great way to start.