10 Rare Bicentennial Quarter Are Worth $250 million Each — Still in circulation

The 1976 Bicentennial Quarter, minted to commemorate 200 years of American independence, remains a nostalgic and historical gem.

While most of these quarters are still worth their face value—just 25 cents—certain ultra-rare versions have stunned collectors and investors alike, fetching eye-popping prices due to their rarity, minting errors, and unique characteristics.

Let’s explore the most valuable Bicentennial Quarters and what sets them apart in the world of coin collecting.

1. The $250 Million Mystery Quarter

Dubbed the “holy grail” of Bicentennial Quarters, this rumored coin is said to possess an extraordinary combination of minting errors and possibly rare materials. Although its existence is unconfirmed, its legendary status keeps collectors on high alert—just in case one surfaces.

2. Double Die Obverse Quarter

This variety was struck twice during minting, resulting in visibly doubled text and numbers. Such a mistake dramatically increases its rarity and value. Some examples have reportedly been sold for more than $69 million.

3. Off-Center Strike Quarter

Caused by the coin blank being misaligned during the minting process, this error results in an uneven or partially struck design. The more off-center the image, the more collectible—and valuable—the coin becomes, with some surpassing $200,000 in value.

4. Overstruck Quarter

These quarters are struck on an existing coin—sometimes a foreign coin or a U.S. dime—creating a fascinating blend of designs. Their uniqueness makes them highly desirable, and collectors have paid more than $250,000 for standout examples.

5. Silver Proof Quarter

Unlike the typical clad quarters, these proof versions contain 40% silver and were made specifically for collectors. Well-preserved examples from mint sets can sell for $15,000 or more.

6. 1976-S Silver MS69 Quarter

Struck at the San Francisco Mint, this coin boasts an MS69 grade—just one notch below a flawless MS70. Its exceptional condition helped one sell for $19,200 at auction.

7. 1976-D Clad MS68 Quarter

This Denver-minted coin stands out for its pristine condition, earning it an MS68 grade. One such quarter sold for over $6,400, a testament to the value of quality in clad coinage.

8. 1976 Clad MS67+ Quarter

While it may look like any regular quarter, this example received a rare MS67+ grade, making it highly collectible. Its near-perfect state pushed its auction value up to $1,821.

9. 1976-S Clad PR67 Proof Quarter

Proof coins are specially made for collectors, with enhanced detail and finish. This San Francisco-minted quarter received a PR67 grade, contributing to its impressive value of over $6,000.

10. 1976-S Silver Proof Quarter

Containing 40% silver and struck to perfection, this proof coin has both aesthetic and metal value. High-grade examples have been known to fetch as much as $13,500.

Top 10 Most Valuable Bicentennial Quarters

No.	Type of Rare Bicentennial Quarter	Estimated Value
1	Legendary Error Quarter	$250 Million
2	Double Die Obverse	$69 Million+
3	Off-Center Strike	$200,000+
4	Overstruck Quarter	$250,000+
5	Silver Proof	$15,000+
6	1976-S Silver MS69	$19,200
7	1976-D Clad MS68	$6,462.50
8	1976 Clad MS67+ Regular Strike	$1,821
9	1976-S Clad PR67 Proof	$6,038
10	1976-S Silver Proof	$13,500

Final Thoughts

While millions of Bicentennial Quarters were minted, only a few rare versions hold immense value due to unusual characteristics, pristine conditions, or rare production errors. If you happen to come across one of these coins, it might be worth more than you ever imagined.

FAQs